Health care capitalists want to see profits, not just cool ideas : Shots


The Westin St. Francis San Francisco on Union Sq. resort hosted this yr’s JPMorgan Healthcare Convention — the primary because the onset of the coronavirus pandemic. (Darius Tahir/KHN)

Darius Tahir/KHN

conceal caption

toggle caption

Darius Tahir/KHN

The Westin St. Francis San Francisco on Union Sq. resort hosted this yr’s JPMorgan Healthcare Convention — the primary because the onset of the coronavirus pandemic. (Darius Tahir/KHN)

Darius Tahir/KHN

SAN FRANCISCO — Well being care’s enterprise class returned to its San Francisco sanctuary final week for JPMorgan’s annual well being care confab, on the gilded Westin St. Francis resort on Union Sq.. After a two-year pandemic pause, the temper among the many executives, bankers and startup founders in attendance had the aura of a reunion — as they gossiped about promotions, work-from-home routines, who’s getting what investments. Dressed of their capitalist greatest — starting from brilliant-blue or pastel-purple blazers to puffy-coat stylish — they thronged to huge events held in artwork galleries and eating places.

However the get together was tinged with new anxiousness: Would the large cash invested in well being care resulting from COVID-19 proceed to move? Would traders ask to see outcomes — that means earnings — slightly than simply cool concepts?

The buzzy convention had simply as many phrases about earnings as about sufferers. The principally maskless crowd spoke English, French, Japanese — and, in fact, cash.

Moreover the company and funding varieties, attendees routinely noticed stunning characters — like superstar physician Mehmet Oz, contemporary off his Senate loss, holding courtroom within the foyer on Jan. 10.

If the vibe within the resort’s congested halls was upbeat — or, not less than, cheery — beneath there was a frisson of hysteria as all had been conscious that the well being care enterprise bonanza appears to be slowing down.

The convention began with a sidewalk protest of pharmaceutical firm Gilead Sciences, whose medication combating HIV and hepatitis C are fabulously efficient — and fabulously costly. Throughout the pandemic, Congress for the primary time has arrange a plan to permit Medicare to barter U.S. drug costs, that are by far the very best on the planet. In a press release, firm spokesperson Catherine Cantone mentioned Gilead is the most important non-public funder of HIV packages within the U.S., including, “Gilead’s position in ending the HIV and hepatitis epidemics is to find, develop, and guarantee entry to our life-saving medicines.”

‘A difficult yr’

Then there’s the financial surroundings, which is popping treacherous. Journalists at monetary publication Bloomberg recognized an absence of thrilling offers. Startup executives — who beforehand discovered tens of millions of {dollars} in investments simple to return by — appeared obligated to point out ends in their impromptu pitches in bars and low outlets. Enterprise executives of all stripes promised they both presently made earnings or had been about to … quickly.

“I feel it is a difficult yr,” mentioned Hemant Taneja, CEO of the enterprise capital agency Basic Catalyst, throughout one panel. He prompt that giant swaths of well being tech startups had been overvalued and that their shoppers will probably be extra interested by whether or not they’re really offering helpful providers.

The brand new message from potential traders was clear. “The thought you would develop and never be worthwhile is useless, gone,” mentioned Dr. Jon Cohen, CEO of the psychological well being startup Talkspace, in an interview.

Some tried to rejoice each monetary and humanitarian success. BioNTech co-founder Uğur Şahin was interrupted by applause throughout a presentation because the developer, with Pfizer, of the mRNA vaccine recounted the pictures’ position in combating the pandemic. And that was earlier than he touted his firm’s position in lowering infectious illness, saving lives, and assembly international well being wants for tuberculosis and malaria.

The dialog later turned to the pricing of his firm’s flagship vaccine — which it is jockeying to set at greater than $100 a dose, up from a mean authorities buy worth of $20.69. 100 bucks is a good worth contemplating the “well being economics,” BioNTech’s chief technique officer, Ryan Richardson, argued: the hospitalizations and severe outcomes averted.

A mind-bending remark

There was some cognitive dissonance on the convention. Think about drugstore large CVS — which is steadily increasing past its retail roots into medical insurance and first care. CVS Well being CEO Karen Lynch mentioned that as a part of its well being enterprise the corporate is all of the elements that underlie being effectively. “Well being is not simply concerning the engagement with the supplier; it is about all the opposite elements — together with housing and diet,” she mentioned. Left unaddressed was the sight usually greeting CVS prospects upon getting into a retailer: sweet, chips, and different processed meals.

For critics, it was a mind-bending remark. “The final I heard, CVS was a for-profit firm, not a social welfare company,” mentioned Marion Nestle, a researcher who’s a longtime critic of the meals trade. “It sells junk meals that make folks sick and medicines to deal with these diseases. How’s that for a nifty enterprise mannequin!”

CVS spokesperson Ethan Slavin provided a really completely different imaginative and prescient, one wherein CVS is in search of to be a premier well being and wellness vacation spot. “We’re all the time evolving our meals and beverage assortment to offer more healthy, on-trend merchandise.” It is usually supporting packages to bolster meals availability in underserved areas, he added.

Some techies encountered new skepticism about “synthetic intelligence.” Ginkgo Bioworks co-founder Jason Kelly famous throughout his presentation that individuals on the convention heard a lot about synthetic intelligence throughout the conferences, “they need to cease listening to it.” (Ginkgo’s AI, used to assist pharmaceutical and biotech analysis, he mentioned, was completely different than the remainder.)

One surgeon, Dr. Rajesh Aggarwal, discovered conversations with financiers concerning the stealth startup he based, which focuses on metabolic well being, had been targeted on silver bullets. “Inform me if I make investments on this, I will 10x” the outlay, he mentioned, paraphrasing the bankers. Many, he mentioned, wished to “do some good as effectively” for sufferers.

Aggarwal felt the traders had been searching for easy options to well being issues. And one merchandise match that invoice: a brand new class of medicine — GLP-1 agonists, a kind of remedy that aids in weight reduction however will seemingly need to be taken for lengthy intervals. Some analysts are projecting these medication will probably be value $50 billion. The bankers, Aggarwal felt, aren’t “fascinated by well being care,” they’re “fascinated by the {dollars} connected to the tablet.”

KHN (Kaiser Well being Information) is a nationwide, editorially impartial program of the Kaiser Household Basis.